Great post
@Jushi85, Let's see.
1. Story/Lore - When I play a game, I want the story to take hold of me and not let go until I have finished it. If I am playing an MMO, I expect a good amount of Lore from the game. I will use Warcraft as a prime example. Across all of their games, RTS to MMO, they have such a rich lore that stays consistent across all their platforms. I have spent more time reading Wiki's and Books about game lore than I care to admit. I will even read lore about games I don't play, I know, I am sick. The writer should be able to dig hooks into the player, reel them in, and not let them go. If I don't make a connection with the characters, in my eyes, it lessons the quality of the game.
2. Customization - I agree with
@NinjaGirl. I like playing games that allow me to customize either my character or aspects in the game. I have played great games that don't feature any customizing, but when it is available it makes me that much more happy. Skyrim's character customization was great and then the addon that let you customize and build your own house. 2 thumbs up. Even in GTA V Online you were able to customize what your character looked like, what clothes they could wear, etc. In SWTOR you can purchase and customize your own personal and guild strongholds. It's the little things like that that make a big difference to me.
3. Cooperative Game Play - Good Co-Op games seem to be all dead and gone. This upsets me! I am a huge fan of cooperative games. I remember
@RivaCom and I playing Army of Two Co-Op Story Mode. It made a mediocre game great. We were able to play through and experience the story, all while strategizing and creating different ways to get past X obstacle.
4. Full Immersion - I guess this could be grouped with number 1, but I am giving it its own number. One of the reasons I play games is to escape to a different world where I can be anything. I want that game to then tug at my emotions to the point where it gets a reaction out of me. If there is an enemy I am interacting with, I want to him to actually make me angry. Final Fantasy X comes to mind. I remember while playing that game, feeling such a broad range of emotion. Anger, Sadness, and of course Happiness. Games that can yield physical reactions out of you make the experience much more significant and memorable.
5. Multiplayer - Every now and then I will sit down and play a game by myself. It doesn't happen too often though. I love the interaction with other, like minded gamers. A lot of games have multiplayer modes, and I am glad to see more and more coming out. If I have the ability to play with my friends, then it is a huge plus. Especially in First Person genre's. I will play the story mode solo, but doing multiplayer online doesn't really interest me unless I am playing with friends. You will never see me playing a Mutliplayer FPS solo.